Are clashes necessary in Dancehall and Reggae music?

Are clashes necessary in Dancehall and Reggae music? - THE December 26, 2011 staging of Sting — dubbed Rumours of War — saw promoter Isaiah Laing returning to the clash format.

He alluded to the fact that clashes worked better in attracting patrons to the event. Therefore, for him to see any return on his investment, this was the route he would have to trod.


Lyrical and sound system clashes have been an integral part of Jamaica's music since its beginnings, but is it really necessary in today's world?

Stone Love Movement CEO Winston 'Wee Pow' Powell says clashes are definitely not good for the industry. "Clash does nothing to the industry but bring negative vibration," he said, pointing out that just because Sting did not attract the numbers when it stayed away from clashing, doesn't mean it couldn't have worked.

"Everything takes time, look at Tony Rebel's show; it is one of the biggest shows right now and it's embraced by the Jamaica Tourist Board. It's that way because it is clean. Everything takes time to come to perfection," Powell said.

For Powell, whether it's dancehall deejays or sound system selectors engaged in clashing, it is still not good. However, he says if it's a sound system against a system then that's different.

"If your system is more powerful, you will be more dominant. That competition never ends, it's from day one. A selector must know that he must at all times try to please his audience," Powell pointed out.

For ethno musicologist Dr Dennis Howard, clashing and competition is a part of our Caribbean culture and he sees nothing wrong with it.

"People love the excitement because tracing is a type of clashing and competition and that is part of rural and urban culture. Even at the intellectual level, a legal debate is good," said Howard.

According to Howard, like with any other competitions, there must be rules. "In boxing, you are not allowed to hit below the belt.

"At sound clash and concert, it has got personal because

there are no established rules of the game," he said, highlighting the fact that some artistes engage in personal attacks on their opponent's sexuality, their mothers and make other negative comments. "That has generated in the kind of mayhem transpired over the years. It has caused people to lose earning, cost people's lives and reputations. Once you have rules of engagement in clashing, it is still a viable option," the musicologist asserted.

Music insider and Observer columnist Clyde McKenzie said there is a place for musical clashes but "in its purest form".

"In it's ideal form, clashing is something sublime, something beautiful. Clashing requires a certain level of sophistication in terms of a sense of humour, and an understanding of the issues and articulating it."

Clashing can be fun when you see two people who are witty standing up and competing against each other," shared McKenzie, while admitting that the music industry has suffered immensely from bad handling of stage clashes. "We don't take it as entertainment, we take it personal. How clashes have unfolded has been very bad for the business."

Going forward, McKenzie says clashing has its purpose and should not be done away with. "We need to refrain from personal and ad hominem attacks and use wit and humour," he advised.

Kool FM's disc jock and musicologist Michael Barnett is of the opinion that a clash is not needed as it incites fans and that he says is definitely not good for the industry.

"When I go back in the day with Prince Buster and Derrick Morgan, the music was friendly. It was never advertised as a clash. It was friendly rivalry through their music," he said, adding that this new clash culture is being promoted to "rev up the people" all with the desire put numbers in the venue.

"Fans take the clash outside of the venue on to their daily lives. It has caused harm to people in the past. I don't think it should be promoted."

Source: Jamaicaobserver.com

Return to Dancehall Reggae world homepage from Are Clashes Necessary in Dancehall and Reggae Music page

Return to Dancehall Sound Clash from Are Clashes Necessary in Dancehall and Reggae Music

Dancehall artiste Shenseea

Shenseea Claims "Princess Of Dancehall" Critics Hits Back

Dancehall artiste Shenseea yesterday claimed her spot among the female dancehall royalty when she dubbed herself dancehall's 'princess' in a post to her Instagram page.
The post took on a life of its own, sparking debate about which female dancehall artiste was deserving of the title princess, since Spice is the queen.Read full article here

Rygin King said Alkaline Not On his Level

Dancehall artiste Rygin King might be losing a few fans after comments he made about Alkaline, not on his level.  During a live broadcast on his Instagram Montego Bay Based artiste, Rygin King was asked if Alkaline is bigger Read more here

Jay Blaxx

Upcoming dancehall artiste Jay Blaxx was shot and killed in the community of Granville, St James on August 28, 2018.

Reports reaching us are that Jay Blaxx who is from the said community was killed by Read more here

Help us to keep Dancehall & Reggae Music Genres alive. We are asking for a small contribution to Keep our site online. CLICK HERE TO MAKE A CONTRIBUTION.

To have your Music, Video, Album, Press Releases or posted or promoted on our site [Click here to contact us for more info]

Who Is The Most Underrated Reggae Entertainer You know?

Over the years there are a lot of good Dancehall and Reggae music entertainers who has been pushed unto the back burner for some reason not of their own.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO....

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.

Articles On Dancehall Reggae World You Might Have Missed ......

PROMOTIONAL OPPORTUNITY

Producers, Artists, Publicist and Managers Get your  Product Out to Over 20,000 Music industry players.  Our players Include Radio Stations, Sound Systems and Deejays.  Click here to Contact Us For More detail.

Win a digital copy of "Welcome To Jamrock Digital CD" by answering the following question.

As a producer What's the name of the first album produced by Damian Jr Gong Marley on his Ghetto Youths International label?

CLICK HERE TO POST YOUR ANSWER


Send Your Music, Video and Press Releases to info@dancehallreggaeworld.com